Goodal Heartleaf vs. Anua Heartleaf Silky

Both build their sunscreen around heartleaf as the headline calming ingredient, both fragrance-free, a genuine direct face-off rather than an apples-to-oranges pairing.

Two sunscreens built around the same headline ingredient, both fragrance-free, which makes price, formula breadth, and real-world availability the actual deciding factors.

Goodal runs $0.34 per milliliter ($17.00 for 50mL). Anua runs $0.36 per milliliter ($18.00 for 50mL). Goodal is slightly cheaper.

Goodal confirms heartleaf extract and glycerin, a deliberately simple formula. Anua confirms heartleaf extract, centella asiatica, and niacinamide, addressing calming and tone together in one sunscreen.

Goodal placed #3 in Olive Young's Sun Care category in 2025, a genuine credential, and its page notes it's genuinely fragrance-free, unlike several sunscreens in this category that market themselves as gentle while still containing added fragrance. Anua carries strong TikTok-driven virality and real demand, but that same demand has led to intermittent restocks at some retailers.

For the simplest, cheapest, award-backed heartleaf option, Goodal is the safer, more consistently available pick. If you want niacinamide's tone benefits added alongside heartleaf and don't mind occasional restock waits, Anua's broader formula and social proof are real, just check stock before committing to it as your only sunscreen.

Browse the rest of our sunscreen coverage.